Quick answer. Shrewsbury Borough, Monmouth County, had a 2025 general tax rate of 1.661 per $100 of assessed value, and the average residential bill was $14,198 on an average assessment of $854,795. A bill is your assessed value × 1.661 ÷ 100. Source: 2025 General Tax Rates and 2025 Average Residential Statistics, NJ Division of Taxation.
General rate (2025)
1.661used to compute a bill
Effective rate (2025)
1.787for comparing towns only
Average residential bill
$14,19812th of 53 in the county
Average ratio
92.46%assessed to true value
Estimate a Shrewsbury Borough property tax bill
Enter a value to see the 2025 tax at Shrewsbury Borough's general rate.
For the current year's rate and your exact bill, ask the Shrewsbury Borough tax collector. For a different town, use the statewide calculator.
What homes at different prices pay in Shrewsbury Borough
Assessments in Shrewsbury Borough averaged 92.46% of true value, so its general rate (1.661) and effective rate (1.787) are close. The table turns each market value into an assessed value with that 92.46% average ratio (Amended Table of Equalized Valuations 2025), then applies the general rate.
| Market value | Est. assessed value | Est. yearly tax |
|---|---|---|
| $300,000 | $277,380 | $4,607 |
| $450,000 | $416,070 | $6,911 |
| $600,000 | $554,760 | $9,215 |
| $800,000 | $739,680 | $12,286 |
| $1,000,000 | $924,600 | $15,358 |
Individual assessments vary around the town average, so a home's real assessed value can be higher or lower than the estimate here. The figure on your own bill or assessment notice is the one that counts.
Shrewsbury Borough by the numbers
- Every $100,000 of assessed value in Shrewsbury Borough carried $1,661 of 2025 tax, or $138 a month.
- The average Shrewsbury Borough home was assessed at $854,795 and billed $14,198, about $1,183 a month or $3,550 a quarter.
- At the 92.46% average ratio, $854,795 of assessed value stands for roughly $924,502 of market value.
- For tax year 2027, a Shrewsbury Borough home truly worth $450,000 falls inside the certified range when it is assessed between $354,555 and $479,655.
How Shrewsbury Borough compares
Shrewsbury Borough's 2025 effective tax rate of 1.787 is the 17th highest of 53 Monmouth County municipalities and the 419th highest of 564 in New Jersey. It is above the county median of 1.576 and below the statewide median of 2.140. Its average residential bill of $14,198 ranks 12th of 53 in the county and 85th of 563 statewide, $2,855 more than the median Monmouth County town's $11,343.
The towns closest to it in Monmouth County by effective rate:
| Town | General rate | Effective rate | Avg residential bill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neptune Township | 1.770 | 1.866 | $10,822 |
| Farmingdale Borough | 1.725 | 1.789 | $9,493 |
| Shrewsbury Borough | 1.661 | 1.787 | $14,198 |
| Red Bank Borough | 1.822 | 1.780 | $10,937 |
| Asbury Park City | 1.752 | 1.763 | $11,178 |
See all 53 Monmouth County towns in one sortable table.
If a Shrewsbury Borough assessment looks too high
Assessment appeals go to the Monmouth County Board of Taxation: Hall of Records, 1 East Main Street, Freehold, NJ 07728, phone (732) 431-7404 (State contact list, September 2026). The Division's appeals page gives the filing deadline as January 15 (the alternate calendar the Division lists for Burlington, Gloucester and Monmouth counties).
An owner must show the assessment doesn't fairly reflect true market value or falls outside the common level range. For tax year 2027 the range certified for Shrewsbury Borough is 78.79% to 106.59%, around an average ratio of 92.69% (2026 Average Ratios and Common Level Ranges). You appeal the assessment, not the tax rate. This page describes the State's published process and is not legal advice.
Related: Set-aside planner: how much to save from each paycheck · NJ senior tax relief checker · NJ property tax relief for seniors · NJ SALT deduction calculator
The borough figures above come from the State's published tables (rates, average residential statistics, equalized valuations, 2027 ranges, definitions), opened and checked November 2026. Not tax or legal advice, and MCC Solutions is not affiliated with the State, the county board or the borough. Exemptions, deductions, appeals, added assessments and the newer year's rate all change a real bill.
Common questions
What is the property tax rate in Shrewsbury Borough, Monmouth County?
The 2025 general tax rate was 1.661 per $100 of assessed value, from the Division of Taxation's 2025 General Tax Rates table. That is the rate applied to an assessed value. The effective rate, the State's figure for comparing towns, was 1.787.
What is the average property tax bill in Shrewsbury Borough?
$14,198 in 2025 on an average residential assessment of $854,795, according to the Division's 2025 Average Residential Statistics. It ranked 12th of 53 in Monmouth County.
How do I work out my own Shrewsbury Borough property tax?
Multiply your assessed value by 1.661 and divide by 100. If you only know market value, multiply it by 92.46% first, the town's average ratio of assessed to true value; a $450,000 home works out to about $6,911 a year that way. Your own assessment is on your bill and may sit above or below the average.
Is this the 2026 rate for Shrewsbury Borough?
No. It is the 2025 rate, the latest year in the Division's general tax rate table when this page was checked (November 2026). The Shrewsbury Borough tax collector can give you the current year's rate.
Is Shrewsbury Borough a high-tax town for Monmouth County?
By effective rate, the State's figure for comparing towns, the borough is 17th highest of 53 in Monmouth County at 1.787; the county's highest is Keansburg Borough at 2.429 and its lowest is Loch Arbour Village at 0.412. By average residential bill it is 12th of 53, at $14,198.